Fund Frequently Asked Questions
Voluntary After-Tax Contributions and 401(m) Testing
  1. What is the 401(m) test?
  2. Why is the test done separately for each YMCA?
  3. How is the 401(m) test done?
  4. What happens when a YMCA fails the 401(m) test?
  5. Can a YMCA perform this test during the year?
  6. When will I be notified?
  7. If money is returned to me as a result of the 401(m) test, is it taxable?
  8. What happens if my contributions and interest are returned to me?
  9. Can I roll over the returned amount to an IRA?
  10. Can I deposit the returned amount into the 403(b) Smart Account?
  11. Can I redeposit any of the returned amount as an after-tax contribution?
  12. How can I avoid having my contributions returned to me?
  13. Where can I find additional information?
 Back to Main Topics

1.  What is the 401(m) test?
401(m) refers to a section of the Internal Revenue Code that governs contributions to retirement plans. The 401(m) test is a non-discrimination test that is performed annually and relates to voluntary after-tax contributions. The test involves comparing voluntary after-tax contributions to a retirement plan made by highly compensated employees to those contributions made by non-highly compensated employees, in order to ensure that highly compensated employees are not favored.

A person who earned more than $105,000 in calendar year 2008 was considered "Highly Compensated" by IRS standards; the Fund used that amount in our 401(m) testing of each YMCA for the Retirement Plan year of July 1, 2008 to June 30, 2009.

 
 Back to Top  Back to Main Topics
2.  Why is the test done separately for each YMCA?
The YMCA Retirement Plan is a "multiple employer" plan with nearly 900 independently incorporated YMCAs.
 
 Back to Top  Back to Main Topics
3.  How is the 401(m) test done?
The test is based on a very complex formula, involving salary history, voluntary after-tax contributions, and a ratio analysis for each YMCA.

A YMCA passes the test when the following calculation is satisfied:

 
 Back to Top  Back to Main Topics
4.  What happens when a YMCA fails the 401(m) test?
Based on an excess contribution calculation, a portion or all of the highly compensated employees' voluntary after-tax contributions must be returned to them, along with any interest earned on those amounts.
 
 Back to Top  Back to Main Topics
5.  Can a YMCA perform this test during the year?
This test can only be done by the Retirement Fund at the end of the plan year (July 1 through June 30). Since voluntary after-tax contributions may be remitted directly to the Fund, the YMCA will not necessarily have complete data until our plan year end.
 
 Back to Top  Back to Main Topics
6.  When will I be notified?
IRS rules require that the testing be completed and any excess contributions and interest returned within 2½ months after the end of the plan year. Since the YMCA Retirement Plan year ends on June 30, testing must be completed and excess amounts returned no later than September 15.
 
 Back to Top  Back to Main Topics
7.  If money is returned to me as a result of the 401(m) test, is it taxable?
The voluntary after-tax contributions returned are not taxable. However, the interest earned on the voluntary after-tax contributions is taxable.
 
 Back to Top  Back to Main Topics
8.  What happens if my contributions and interest are returned to me?
If your contributions are returned, then the interest earned on those contributions is considered taxable income and should be reported on your tax return covering the year it was returned. The Fund is required to send you an IRS Form 1099-R related to 2008 no later than September 15, 2009. Interest returned that is earned in 2009 will be reported on IRS Form 1099-R by January 31, 2010.
 
 Back to Top  Back to Main Topics
9.  Can I roll over the returned amount to an IRA?
Amounts returned as a result of 401(m) testing cannot be rolled over.
 
 Back to Top  Back to Main Topics
10.  Can I deposit the returned amount into the 403(b) Smart Account?
No, tax-deferred saving may only be done through payroll deductions.
 
 Back to Top  Back to Main Topics
11.  Can I redeposit any of the returned amount as an after-tax contribution?
If you redeposit the amount as an after-tax contribution to the Retirement Plan, it is still subject to non-discrimination testing in the future.
 
 Back to Top  Back to Main Topics
12.  How can I avoid having my contributions returned to me?
Maximize your contributions to a 403(b) Smart Account since this account is not subject to 401(m) testing.
 
 Back to Top  Back to Main Topics
13.  Where can I find additional information?
 Back to Top  Back to Main Topics
Give Us Your Feedback